So I touched a nerve today with a
Twitter post. I mentioned
Camp Quest as an alternative to vacation bible school. Apparently my bad grammar indicated a direct comparison between free thought and VBS. I'll have to defer to the English majors and language enthusiasts on that point because I am certainly not qualified to argue about such topics. What I would like to do, however, is clarify what I said, why I said it and how my statements may have been misinterpreted.
First let's reprint the initial tweet.
"I hear quite a bit about Vacation Bible School but what about something for free thinkers? - Camp Quest to the rescue - http://bit.ly/16xzGA"
Outside of the grammatical error that apparently exists in that statement, the biggest error is in the term "free thinker". Broken in two like that, the term would seems to have a fairly nebulous definition. It would be fair to interpret the term as meaning something analogous to "open minded". That, however, was not the intended use of the word/phrase. The word "Freethinker" has a specific meaning which I will quote from the
Freedom From Religion Foundation.
"
free-think-er n. A person who forms opinions about
religion on the basis of reason, independently of tradition, authority,
or established belief. Freethinkers include atheists, agnostics and
rationalists."
The FFRF goes on to say:
"No one can be a freethinker who demands conformity to a bible, creed,
or messiah. To the freethinker, revelation and faith are invalid, and
orthodoxy is no guarantee of truth."
Based on this definition, there is a clear difference between freethinkers and VBS goers/supporters. Being one precludes you from being the other. Therefore, any freethought summer program is a religion free alternative to VBS. Any other meaning is neither expressed or implied.
Obviously I should not have put a space between the words "free" and "thinkers" in my tweet although I wonder if typing the word correctly would have changed the responses I received. The intention, however, was to give publicity to an alternative to VBS for people who might call themselves freethinkers.
I would also like to point out what I didn't do. I didn't say anything negative about VBS nor did attack consumers of VBS programs. I didn't even imply anything negative about VBS. I only mentioned an alternative. If the terms "free thinker" or "Freethinker" are threatening, then all I can say is that it was not my purpose or intent. I made no statements impuning the "open mindedness" of anyone involved in VBS and such arguments are completely unrelated to the existense of alternatives to VBS. I know I have been fairly vocal in my rejection of religion and I will continue to be so but in this case I felt I was being quite reserved and fair. I have seen multiple tweets and Facebook updates mentioning VBS and I just wanted to mention an alternative. I know there are people out there that would like to know about such programs as I have been contacted privately by individuals who feel the same way about religion as I do but aren't yet comfortable expressing their thoughts publicly. If I can alert those people to programs they or their children might be interested in then it is both my desire and duty to do so.
Further information on Freethinker philosophy can be found at the
Freedom From Religion Foundation.
Recent Comments